Birmingham, England, United Kingdom Dec 20, 2009

OsheavsCruger

🔥
161.6K
Views
697
Likes
371
Comments

Votes

Members
No votes yet.

Be the first member to cast a vote on this battle!

Community Verdict

Verdict
Winner
55% confidence
Score
21

The official decision went to Cruger, but the fan sentiment in the comments is overwhelmingly in favor of Oshea, with a significant number of viewers calling the result a 'robbery'. Based on the majority fan opinion that Oshea won the first two rounds and the overtime, he is designated the winner here, albeit with low confidence to reflect the highly controversial nature of the battle.

Round-by-Round
Rd 1OsheaA very close round. Fans praised Cruger's hilarious angles and setups, but the consensus leaned slightly towards Oshea's more direct and impactful punchlines and comedic delivery.
Rd 2OsheaOshea's performance in the second was widely considered his strongest, with his 'Medusa' line being a major highlight. While Cruger's 'O-shape' line landed well, fans felt Oshea took the round more decisively.
Rd 3CrugerCruger was widely seen as taking this round. His material was sharp and his performance was strong, even with the technical issue of lost footage. Many fans who scored the battle for Oshea still conceded this round to Cruger.
Analysis

In a classic, old-school Don't Flop clash, two of the UK's most revered comedic talents, Oshea and Cruger, went head-to-head in a battle celebrated for its pure entertainment value. Cruger came with his signature clever writing, landing haymakers like the now-legendary 'pint under his top' scheme. Oshea countered with his raw, scouse wit and charisma, dropping memorable lines like his 'Medusa' punch that had the crowd roaring.

The battle's legacy, however, is defined by its controversial conclusion. Despite a technical hiccup with lost footage in the third round, the judges awarded the victory to Cruger. This decision immediately ignited a firestorm of debate in the comments that persists to this day.

A large and vocal segment of the fanbase felt Oshea was robbed, arguing he clearly took the first two rounds and the promotional overtime. Regardless of the victor, the battle stands as a beloved time capsule of a grittier era in UK battle rap, showcasing two unique talents at the top of their game.

01Cruger's 'stick up in a shop with a pint under his top' line was a massive crowd-pleaser and the most frequently quoted bar from the battle.
02Oshea's punchline, 'You couldn't get stoned if you shared a flat with Medusa,' was a standout moment that fans repeatedly praised for its cleverness.
03The official judges' decision awarding the battle to Cruger sparked immediate and lasting debate among fans, with many calling it a robbery.
04The third round footage was partially lost, replaced by still images and audio, which was a point of frustration for many viewers.
What fans loved
  • Viewers widely praised the battle as a hilarious and highly entertaining clash of two comedic titans.
  • Cruger's 'pint under his top' and 'O-shape' lines were frequently cited as standout moments of clever writing.
  • Oshea's 'Medusa' line was a fan-favorite punchline, celebrated for its creativity.
  • Many fans expressed a strong sense of nostalgia for the raw, unfiltered style of early Don't Flop battles.
  • The chemistry and mutual respect between the two battlers were appreciated by the audience.
Criticisms
  • The judges' decision to award the win to Cruger was the most significant point of contention, with many fans believing Oshea was robbed.
  • Several comments noted frustration with the loss of video footage for the third round.
  • The host's performance was criticized by some viewers, who found his presence intrusive.
  • A few viewers mentioned having difficulty understanding the thick regional accents, particularly Oshea's.

Chat

Members Only

Log in to view the chat and share your thoughts on this matchup.