Votes
Be the first member to cast a vote on this battle!
Community Verdict
This is a highly debated classic where the victor depends on what a fan values more. While Brooklyn Carter's aggression and strong first round earned him many supporters, a slight majority of fan sentiment favors Steams. His second round is consistently cited as one of the best rounds in Proving Grounds history, and his complex, multi-layered wordplay gave him a lyrical edge that resonated with viewers over the years, giving him the win in a photo finish.
In a clash that would become Proving Grounds lore, Steams and Brooklyn Carter delivered a bar-heavy classic that fans still debate nearly a decade later. This battle was the epitome of a style clash: Steams, the lyrical technician with mind-bending schemes, against Brooklyn Carter, the aggressive performer with a commanding stage presence and hard-hitting punches. From the jump, the energy was electric, with Carter's first round being hailed as an all-time great opener.
But Steams fired back with a second round that many fans consider his magnum opus, a flawless display of intricate writing that shifted the entire battle's momentum. The fallout from this war of words was a divided fanbase, with many calling it 2-1 for either MC. Its legacy is that of a quintessential PG battle—two hungry emcees fighting for a spot, leaving everything on the stage and creating a moment that outshined many main events of its time.
- Fans overwhelmingly consider this battle a timeless classic with immense replay value.
- Steams' second round was widely celebrated as a masterclass in complex wordplay and one of the best rounds ever.
- Brooklyn Carter's aggressive performance and powerful delivery were praised as top-tier.
- Many viewers felt Carter's first round was one of the strongest openings in Proving Grounds history.
- The hunger and raw energy from both competitors were seen as a breath of fresh air compared to veteran battles.
- The winner remains one of the most debated topics from the PG era, with no clear consensus.
- Some fans felt Steams' complex bars were occasionally overcomplicated or difficult to decipher in real-time.
- A portion of the audience found Brooklyn Carter's style to be lyrically simpler than his opponent's.
- The hyper-energetic crowd and entourage were viewed as a distraction by some, who felt they gassed up mediocre lines.
Related Battles
Chat
Members Only
Log in to view the chat and share your thoughts on this matchup.