Votes
Be the first member to cast a vote on this battle!
Community Verdict
Star Smilez secured a decisive victory, primarily due to Melato Black's repeated stumbles and chokes across all three rounds. While Melato Black showcased flashes of strong lyrical ability, her performance issues prevented her from effectively delivering her material, allowing Star Smilez to maintain composure and deliver her bars consistently.
The QOTR closed room battle between Star Smilez and Melato Black saw Star Smilez emerge with a clear victory, largely due to her consistent delivery against Melato Black's undeniable talent hampered by severe performance issues. Star Smilez, a veteran of the closed room, showcased a confident and polished performance, delivering her bars with a steady flow that kept the crowd engaged. Melato Black, often praised for her pen game and unique style, struggled significantly with stumbles and chokes in every round.
Despite these setbacks, she managed to land some memorable lines, with her 'ISIS' bar being a standout moment that drew significant fan appreciation. However, the inability to deliver her full rounds cleanly ultimately cost her the battle. Fans acknowledged Star Smilez's improved form and solid execution, celebrating her well-deserved win.
The battle, while not a back-and-forth classic due to Melato's struggles, served as a testament to Star Smilez's resilience and ability to perform under pressure, while also highlighting Melato Black's immense potential once she masters her stage presence and recall.
- Star Smilez's consistent delivery and improved performance were widely praised by fans.
- Melato Black's lyrical ability and strong punchlines, particularly the 'ISIS' bar, garnered significant appreciation despite her stumbles.
- Star Smilez's 'money and violence' scheme was highlighted as a potent part of her material.
- Many viewers expressed excitement about Star Smilez's return to form and her confident stage presence.
- Melato Black's frequent stumbles and chokes were a major point of disappointment for viewers, who felt it cost her the battle.
- Several comments expressed frustration with the crowd's noise and interference, suggesting it impacted the battle's flow and Melato's concentration.
- Some viewers felt Star Smilez's material, while consistent, did not always land with high impact or show significant progression.
- Concerns were raised about Melato Black's preparation, with some suggesting she needs more time to rehearse her bars.
Related Battles
Chat
Members Only
Log in to view the chat and share your thoughts on this matchup.